John had gone out for a smoke on the sad grey cracked bit of patio that passed for his flat’s garden. The air was cold and heavy, and the moon was that kind of almost-crescent that looked like it was too bored to make much of an effort and expected congratulations for making any kind of appearance at all.
The end of his cigarette glowed like a firefly. He’d stood here with Susie just last week, her shoulder against his, her head tilted back as she watched the sky. There’d been stars then, and the moon had been full and glowing as though it actually gave a fuck.
He flicked off ash, and it swirled away into the cold night.
“What do you want to do now?” she’d asked.
“Take you back inside and make love to you,” he’d wanted to say. But he’d said, “Dunno. What do you want to do?”
She’d given him that look, that exasperated sigh. “I want to do what you want to do.”
What if he’d said it? Said that he wanted to take her to bed and never let her leave, wanted to fuck her senseless, wanted to make love until she whispered his name with each exhalation and held him and said she’d never leave?
“We could watch a film,” he’d said, and she’d sighed and smiled, and they had gone back inside and watched Star Wars, and she had sat a little apart from him, and he had picked at the cracks in the brown leather sofa and tried not to think about how much he wanted to touch her.
The wind whipped up the final embers of his cigarette, and the sparks flew like little devils into the dark.
Back inside, sitting on his cold bed and staring at his cluttered desk, he seemed poised above a long desert of nothingness, of an infinite stretch of nights smoking alone, sitting in his cold bedroom and staring at the opposite wall.
He cupped his hands around his elbows in an effort to warm himself, but that reminded him too much of a hug, of the hug she’d given him on that last day, just before she’d left for the station. A brief press of her body against his, her chin on his shoulder, and then she was gone.
Just like that, leaving a handful of lukewarm memories and a pot plant that was already starting to wilt.
It sat on his chair, no room for it on the desk, and the weak light from the naked bulb overhead shone dully on its dark green leaves and tightly-closed buds.
How original, he thought. Dumped with a pot plant.
“I’m sorry,” she’d said. “I just, I think we’re in different places, that’s all.” She’d shoved the plant at him, and he’d had to take it. “I got you this.”
Maybe she’d meant it as a magician’s distraction. Watch the right hand, forget what the left is doing.
He’d grasped the pot one-handed, spilling soil. “I don’t understand.”
“No, you don’t.” She’d looked at him sadly. “I’m sorry. But that’s the thing. You don’t understand. And you won’t listen.”
“But — what did I do wrong?”
She shook her head. “We’re incompatible.”
“That’s not true! Please — ” He’d made a movement towards her, and the plant lurched top-heavy in his hand.
“Be careful,” she’d said. “You’ll make a mess.”
He stared at his cluttered desk, at the smug gleam of the plant’s shiny leaves.
He remembered the light pressure of her hug. How she’d stepped back, smiling, one hand adjusting her hair. Smiling. It hadn’t been a happy smile, more a sad “oh well” kind, but still. She’d smiled.
Her smile had been what he’d first liked about her. Her perfect Colgate teeth, the cat-like curve of her lips. God, she’d been so beautiful when she smiled.
And she’d smiled, turned away and got on the train and hadn’t come back.
That fucking smile. It teased him and turned him on and made him hate himself, because she was gone, she’d been so beautiful and for a few months she’d been his and everything was easy, and now she was gone and she’d taken her smile with her, and all that he was left with was that motherfucking plant.
His hand was at his belt before he properly realised what he was planning, but by then he didn’t care. His dick was already hard, and it only took a few fumblings of jeans and boxers to get going, and so he sat on his cold bed and jacked off furiously, miserably, desperately, over the memory of her smile, and the ghostly anticipation of her breasts that he’d never touched, and her mouth that he hadn’t kissed enough. It was short and grim, and he came with a spurt of self-loathing that shot between his fingers and actually landed on the plant perched precariously on the wobbling desk chair.
He felt a stab of victorious satisfaction as the plant’s leaves buckled and drooped. Fuck that plant. And fuck Susie and her beautiful fucking smile.
He kicked out and hit the chair. It spun around, and the plant crashed to the floor and splattered in a mess of fragile pot pieces, soil, and bruised cum-stained leaves all over the carpet.
He sat there for a moment longer as his heartbeat returned to normal, then wiped himself off and lay back on the bed. The sheets were still cold, and now felt slightly clammy. The ceiling swirls peered down at him, and he stared back with his fists clenched behind his head.
Had it been the smoking? Star Wars? For Christ’s sake, was it even the sofa?
He didn’t know. He hadn’t a fucking clue.
What did incompatible even mean? It sounded like one of those vapid labels women put on things when they didn’t have any real reasons to offer. Incompatible made things sounds important and valid, like there was some real problem beyond what do you want to do John and what are you feeling John and what do you think John.
He turned his head and looked at the plant spread all over the floor. Its leaves still had that faint waxy sheen, though whether that was its natural glow or cum, he couldn’t tell. His sense of victory faded with the feeling of release, and it became just one more mess he would have to clean up, along with the wank-crusted tissues and empty crisp packets and dirty socks.
He looked back at the ceiling and closed his eyes. He felt small and pitiful. He couldn’t even hold onto his anger, or convince himself that he could be righteously indignant about this; he felt numb and hopeless. Despair crawled down his throat and gestated in his stomach.
The bed creaked as someone sat down and settled their weight on the edge of the mattress. He opened his eyes, then recoiled in shock.
A man was sitting on the end of his bed. A naked, filthy man with soil falling out of his hair and down his body and from his fingertips. His skin was a patchwork of earth brown and shocking white where the mud had fallen away to reveal the naked skin beneath. He reached across to the desk and picked up the dog-eared copy of The Catcher In The Rye, and began to turn the pages with dirty fingers scabbed with flakes of drying dirt. Crumbs of soil fell from his hands, and he shook them vaguely, flicking earth onto the bed sheets.
John made an inarticulate noise.
The man looked up briefly, his eyes very clear and white in his muddy face. “Sorry,” he said, and went back to the book.
The plant still lay on the carpet, but now it was completely dry and withered. Its leaves were shrivelled like burnt skin, and its stems were thin and brittle. The soil seemed to have got tracked deeper into the carpet without anyone actually touching it.
John hugged his pillow and stared at the man out of the corner of his eye. He was still sitting there reading The Catcher In The Rye. John tried a few times to speak, but couldn’t think what to say. As he opened his mouth for the fifth time, the man closed the book and laid it carefully on the bed beside him. He drew his heels up onto the bed, leaving brown smears on the sheets, and sat with his arms resting on his knees.
“Maybe it was the sex,” he said.
John’s fingers clenched in the pillowcase. “Sorry?”
“You never had sex with Susie,” the man said. “Maybe that was what she was waiting for.”
“She never said that!”
“Did you talk about it with her?”
“Well, no … But she didn’t either! And she’s a — I didn’t want to put pressure on her or make her feel—I’m not that kind of guy.”
The man shrugged. Soil fell from his shoulders. “Maybe that’s significant.”
“What do you mean, significant?”
“Well, it’s important, isn’t it?”
John inhaled sharply. “Well — yes.”
“And yet neither of you made the effort to talk about it.”
“But she — I mean, I thought she’d assume — because it’s different for women, and especially now with all this … I didn’t want to try and ask and then later on have her be like … ”
“She said you didn’t listen.”
“She said I wouldn’t listen. And what does that even mean? I listened all the time.”
“And you still don’t understand.”
John breathed in deeply. He could smell the fresh aroma of new soil, slightly damp, newly turned. It reminded him of a rainy garden, back when he’d lived at home with his mum and had actually had a garden. He pressed his face against the pillow. But there, lingering in its polyester depths was the faint dream of Susie’s perfume, that floral scent that always clung to her and wove itself into the fabric of everything she touched.
“It can’t have just been the sex,” he burst out. “She hated Woody Allen films and I never understood why, and she hated Shaun of the Dead, and she always going on about evening classes and meditation and Eckhart Toile and — I didn’t understand any of it.”
“No, you don’t.”
John squeezed the limp pillow, and caught a fresh mist of florals. “God, this is a mess,” he whispered. “I fucked up. And now I’m so fucking unhappy.”
“I know,” the man said.
“I was only with her for a few months. It shouldn’t affect me this much.”
“Did you love her?” the man asked.
“I don’t know.” John crushed the pillow in his arms. “I think I could have loved her. I could have.”
“But you don’t. So things can change. There’s still hope.”
“Still hope,” John repeated, and he thought of Star Wars, and of Susie’s face bathed in the light of the exploding Death Star. “I hate this. I hate her.”
“Do you really?” the man asked.
“No,” John said. “Yes. Maybe. I don’t know. I want to hate her. She just left, you know? And — and that fucking plant.”
They both looked at the mess on the floor. The man scratched his filthy scalp with a filthy finger. Soil from his hair pattered down onto the confusion of dead roots and broken pot.
“I’m Jack,” the man said.
“I’m John,” John said.
“Yes,” the man said, “I know.”
© 2018 Alice Olivia Scarlett
Alice Olivia Scarlett is a freelance writer and editor. She lives in Thanet with the seagulls and parakeets.